This is my second Jayco Eagle 5th. First was just an eagle and only 3-4 minor warranty issues. All resolved timely and without loss of use. Second unit is a Eagle Premier. Finish and construction very good as was with the previous unit. I did have a few more warranty issues pertaining to the slides and landing gear, but have been resolved and corrected.
Are there things I would change, sure. Unless you design it yourself there are always going to be things you scratch your head about. Is that a deal breaker for me, no. The overall design and layout works nicely for me and met all my must haves.
pluses: 2 year warranty ++. Jayco went above and beyond on last trailer even outside 2yrs. All the added non al a carte items a value with Jayco when you build out similar competitors products. Options were resonable and desired.
negatives: no options on tires, but that is with 90% of them out there and fixable.
Look at construction to truly compare, as that is where you could suffer overall.
2014 375 BHFS Eagle Premier
2014 Ram 3500 Longhorn DRW CC
6.7 CTD, Aisin, 4.10's