Yea, part of the problem with some bad reviews on tires is you usually don't know if the owner took good care of the tires. Like keeping the pressure at correct levels and covering the tires when not in use. Or the age of the tires when the problems occurred because some folks think trailer tires are "good" as long as their is good tread.
Having said all that, I'm surprised you haven't gotten more feedback on this thread. Maxxis and Michelin are two of the top brands that almost always have good reviews. Sometimes hard to find a dealer for Maxxis and sometimes not available in all sizes but those are two excellent brands.
2012 Eagle Super Lite HT 26.5RKS
2005 GMC 2500 SLT HD D/A